Which 3D Printing Material Should You Use? Nylon, Resin, Metal and TPU Compared

Choosing a material is really choosing a set of performance limits. Nylon, photopolymer resin, metal and TPU are the families we see most often in 3D printing, and their strengths and weaknesses sit a long way apart. Rather than starting with price, work through how the part will be used — that alone usually settles which family you need.

1. Where each material family sits

  • Nylon — powder-bed processes (SLS / MJF). Tough and load-bearing, the default for functional parts and small-to-mid batch runs.
  • Photopolymer resin — SLA. The best accuracy and surface finish of the four, suited to appearance parts and fine structures.
  • Metal — SLM. The highest strength and heat resistance, for structural parts, mould inserts and lightweight components.
  • TPU — a flexible material that bends and springs back, for seals, bumpers and anything that has to give.

In one line: load-bearing means nylon, appearance means resin, high temperature and high strength mean metal, elasticity means TPU.

2. Strengths and limits of each material

SLS nylon sample part: Nylon 12 is used for functional and load-bearing parts

Nylon has the best overall balance of strength, toughness and fatigue resistance — it is the family that can make parts meant to be installed and used. Its limits are a matte surface with fine layer lines rather than a high gloss, and a narrow colour range that is usually adjusted through dyeing or bead blasting.

Resin’s advantage is accuracy and surface quality: fine features and clear parts both come out clean. Its limits are weathering and sustained load — under UV exposure or long-term stress it ages and deforms, so it suits the validation stage better than a permanent functional part.

Metal has the highest strength and heat resistance of the four; 316L stainless steel and AlSi10Mg aluminium can make genuine structural parts. The trade-off is a cost and lead time well above plastics, so it is used where a plastic part cannot hold up.

TPU makes structures that bend and flex, with grades available across a range of Shore hardness and elongation at break. It is not as strong as nylon and should not carry primary loads, but it is ideal for seals, bumpers and damping.

3. Primofort’s materials and processes

Primofort runs both powder-bed nylon routes — SLS on a Formlabs Fuse 1+ and MJF on an HP Jet Fusion. Resin parts run on SLA, metal parts on SLM, with FDM and full-colour PolyJet also available. Beyond the standard grades, we produce our own YC120CF nylon carbon fibre, with third-party test data of 50.6 MPa tensile strength, 64 MPa flexural strength and an HDT of 81 °C at 1.8 MPa. Which route a job takes is decided together with the application, budget and service environment — we do not push one route by default.

4. Quick match by purpose

  • Load-bearing, going into testing: nylon first. Where stiffness matters, step up to glass-fibre or carbon-fibre reinforced grades.
  • Appearance and assembly checks only: resin is enough; choose clear resin if you need transparency.
  • High temperature and high strength: metal.
  • Elasticity and cushioning: TPU.
  • Accuracy at low cost: SLA for single parts, SLS / MJF for batches.

5. Reference data for common grades

Grey SLA resin sample: suited to appearance validation and fine structures

Material selection eventually lands on a specific grade. Taking nylon as an example, the common options differ like this:

  • Nylon 12 (general purpose) — around 50 MPa tensile strength and 10% elongation at break; the everyday choice for functional prototypes and end-use parts.
  • Nylon 12 Tough — around 25% elongation at break and 71 J/m impact strength, for durable parts that take repeated impact and bending.
  • Nylon 12 GF (glass-fibre reinforced) — around 4.1 GPa flexural modulus and a 162 °C heat deflection temperature at 1.8 MPa, for structural brackets and high-temperature fixtures.
  • Nylon 11 — around 40% elongation at break and low water absorption, for thin-wall housings, clips and orthoses.
  • Carbon-fibre reinforced grades — tensile modulus above 5 GPa in the X direction and a heat deflection temperature close to 180 °C at 1.8 MPa, for replacing metal parts.

On the metal side, 316L stainless steel is typically above 550 MPa tensile strength, AlSi10Mg aluminium above 350 MPa, and 18Ni300 mould steel higher still. Exact figures depend on the material and process test report — ask your supplier for the data sheet for the grade you are considering.

6. Where selection usually goes wrong

  • Using a resin part as a functional part — nothing shows up in the short term, but sustained load leads to deformation or brittle failure.
  • Ignoring the service environment — nylon parts used outdoors need UV and ageing assessed, and damp environments need nylon’s moisture absorption considered.
  • Comparing unit price only — metal is not in the same cost bracket as the others; judge the whole package, including finishing and lead time.
  • Overlooking what finishing does to performance — dyeing, painting and vapour smoothing all change the surface, so flag it early when dimensions or sealing matter.

Conclusion

If you are not sure which way to go, send the drawing (STL, STEP or IGS are all fine) together with how the part will be used, and Primofort will come back with a material recommendation first, then a quote. If you have a particular grade or process in mind, mention it when you send the files.